Portugal: The Art of Dismantling What You Built
I've been watching Portugal for more than a decade — and not as a distant analyst, but as a long-time resident, someone who has walked those streets, sat in those cafés, and engaged in conversations with people who genuinely believed this small country was in the middle of something historic. They weren't wrong. What Portugal built between 2012 and 2022 was the real thing.
Coming out of an IMF bailout, stripped of fiscal flexibility, watching a generation leave for London and Zurich, the government made a decisive and innovative bet: attract capital and talent with a credible value proposition. The Golden Visa was that proposition – not a gimmick, not a flag-for-sale scheme, but a structured offer to the global HNWI community that said, 'Invest here, and we will be a reliable partner.' The Non-Habitual Resident regime ran alongside it, pulling in EU pensioners, remote workers, and skilled professionals on competitive tax terms. Together, they didn't just bring money — even more importantly, they signalled to the world that Portugal was serious.
And it worked! More than €7–9 billion in direct investment arrived, with analysts estimating a 6x multiplier in total economic output. It is important to note this quantum, as we account for the consequences of current political signals being sent out. For every €1 billion investment under this programme, roughly €6 billion in downstream economic activity was realised. A €3.5 billion data centre anchored at Sines. The Web Summit permanently relocated to Lisbon. Five unicorns. A top-30 global startup ecosystem ranking by 2025. Portugal entered the conversation alongside Tallinn, Amsterdam, and Dublin as a place where serious capital wanted to be invested. I watched Lisbon stop being a beautiful backwater and start becoming a genuine node in the global knowledge economy.
Here's what I find hard to reconcile when I look back: the diagnosis that ended all of this was almost entirely wrong – yet so familiar worldwide – unaffordable housing. Portugal's housing crisis became the political emergency, and the narrative that emerged — wealthy foreigners pricing Portuguese families out of the market — was useful and hollow in equal measure. Transaction data shows domestic buyers accounted for 95% of all 2024 residential purchases. Non-EU buyers paid twice the local average, but for entirely different properties in entirely different markets. They were not competing for the affordable apartment in Setúbal. They never were. The actual drivers were hiding in plain sight all along: Portugal's own 2014 decision to digitalise short-term rental licensing created the Airbnb wave that pushed property values up 34% in Lisbon and Porto's historic centers alone. ECB near-zero rates from 2015 to 2022 drove domestic buying speculation. Construction costs surged 80% in three years, making affordable supply economically impossible. And the population absorbed more than a million new residents in seven years as the manifestation-of-interest pathway ran wide open during COVID — drawing precisely the low-skilled, informal-sector labor migration that the rest of the EU was actively managing down. The tragedy was that the Portuguese government chose the exactly wrong lever.
The Golden Visa real estate route was curtailed in February 2023. The manifestation-of-interest pathway was left open until December 2025. That inversion of priorities is not a footnote — it is the story.
Then came the institutional collapse. SEF was dissolved in October 2023 — not wrong in concept, but catastrophically wrong in sequencing and execution. AIMA inherited 350,000 pending cases on its first day. By 2024, the agency was handling a million emails and 600,000 phone calls annually. Investors who had committed half a million euros to this country waited three, sometimes four, years for a processing decision. I've spoken to people in this community who filed court cases simply to force someone to read their application. The government allocated less than €6 million in its 2025 budget to clear the backlog — a number that communicates, perhaps unintentionally, exactly how seriously the state took its obligations.
This is where the behavioural reality matters as much as the policy error. Residency-by-investment programmes run on a psychological contract. The investor accepts complexity, cost, and patience in exchange for one implicit guarantee: the rules will not be changed against you mid-process. When you violate that contract retroactively — as Portugal did — you don't just lose the investor in front of you. You activate loss aversion at full intensity in one of the most mobile, most networked, most vocal professional communities in the world. The reputational damage from a disastrous investor experience travels faster and further through those networks than any amount of positive marketing could ever recover. The asymmetry is brutal and permanent.
The citizenship law change was the final act. Parliament voted in October 2025 to move the citizenship clock from five years to ten — restarting the timer from card issuance, not application date, with no grandfathering for existing applicants. An investor who applied in 2021 and received their card in 2025 after years of administrative paralysis now qualifies for citizenship in 2035. The debate that erupted in parliament and election campaigns treated this as a live controversy. In the investment community, it wasn't. That conversation had already ended years earlier — ended not by the law, but by the processing delays. The citizenship timeline debate was a moot point for anyone already living through the bureaucratic collapse. What the October 2025 vote accomplished was removing the last shred of credibility that the Portuguese government had left with the global community.
Another very significant point of note for me – whilst the world blames Partido CHEGA for the populist moves that have hurt the state's credibility, the authorship actually rests with the Socialist Party. The Socialist government opened the manifestation-of-interest floodgate. The Socialist government dissolved SEF before AIMA was operationally ready. The Socialist government abolished the NHR in 2024 and curtailed the Golden Visa in 2023. The populist right did not create this crisis — it inherited and amplified it. That sequencing matters enormously for every country currently watching its own centre-left government navigate immigration pressure. The crisis that hands the keys to the populist right is almost always built by the government that precedes it.
The economic bill is real, and is only starting to emerge now. FDI fell 35% in 2025 to its lowest level since COVID. Porto's peak of €1 billion in FDI in 2023 collapsed to €300 million the following year. The Bank of Portugal's own March 2026 economic bulletin acknowledged explicitly that slowing immigration is becoming a headwind to GDP growth. The €26.2 billion in potential data centre economic contribution projected through 2030 is explicitly conditional on stable investment conditions — a condition that the last three years of legislative and bureaucratic turbulence has directly compromised. The NHR abolition removed the high-income tax contribution stream. These effects don't appear immediately in headline GDP figures. But they are compounding, and the full cost has not yet landed.
Lets be clear - Portugal is not in crisis today. Fiscal surpluses three years running. A (high) sovereign rating. GDP growing at double the EU average. The economy is functioning. But functioning is not the same as realising potential, and the higher-value trajectory — the knowledge-economy, technology-investment, globally-connected trajectory that the Golden Visa decade made credible — has been disrupted. The capital that left went somewhere else. New residences and investment schemes have been crafted by other countries, including Ireland, Greece, Spain and now Panama that are willing and open to this very community that once flocked to Portugal.
I've watched enough policy cycles to recognise the pattern. A small open economy builds genuine competitive positioning through credible, consistent policy design. Housing pressure builds — driven by structural domestic failures that are politically difficult to own. A scapegoat emerges — the most visible foreign element, rarely the most causal one. The program is dismantled. The structural problem remains. And the reputational damage to the policy framework outlives the government that caused it by many years.
More in this area
New Zealand Needs a Government That Can Decide
The current election results have brought back all the reasons I have never been comfortable with MMP as the platform for New Zealand’s democracy. I think it brings back the arguments for a different architecture, not a minor…
Creating fiscal headspace by delivering outcomes and not just bills to taxpayers
I am watching the Conservative conference in Birmingham with some anticipation. The party chairman has promised more announcements about scrapping taxes before the week is out. Last week I wrote about Andy Burnham's first…
Youth, Tariffs, and India’s Strategic Autonomy Story
Two recent issues – the youth movement, new tariffs imposed ondemanded and Russian oil purchases and future tariffs of 100% on generics – made me reflect over the foreign policy posture of India. I have never been comfortable…