How Cultural Anxiety, Economic Strain, and New Media Are Redrawing the Political Map
An observation - might be contentious.
As I look at a global surge in right-wing parties and wonder what could be driving it, I see four tightly interconnected vectors that, together
1. The democratisation of media and the rise of podcasters
2. Mass low-skill migration
3. Stubbornly high youth unemployment and continued precarity in a high-productivity future
4. And finally, a widespread backlash against what many ordinary people perceive as extreme liberal positions on gender fluidity and global-vs-domestic humanitarian priorities.
Rise of these four key vectors coincides with the centrist views collapsing, millions of the mainstream populace, who aren’t particularly xenophobic, end up leaning right as a last resort.
Since 2015, migration volume has grown from 221 million to over 281 million (UN/IOM), with low-skilled, young males dominating inflows compared to high-skilled migrants by 2.1:1 in Europe. A 2024 European Economic Review study across Italy found every 1% increase in low-skilled asylum seekers per capita raised radical-right voting 0.5–1%. Other studies conducted across 50+ countries support similar elasticities: double low-skill immigration, double populist vote share. The reaction to high-skill migration is remarkably lower in terms of its impact on right-wing voting.
Add to this, youth’s economic despair. ILO 2025 data show 262 million young people are NEET – not in employment, education or training – a 25% global rate. In Europe, youth on temporary contracts are 15–20% more likely to vote radical right than those with secure jobs. One of the areas less studied, but perhaps has a substantial impact on the rise of the right wing is also the loss of status, over the wage loss.
Media democratisation is another key factor. The number of social media users has jumped from 2.1 billion in 2015 to 5.2 billion today. Reuters Institute and Manifesto Project data show that for a 10% rise in internet penetration, there is a corresponding ~3% rise in right-wing populist vote share driven by algorithmic outrage. A good example would be the role Joe Rogan’s Trump episode played in the 2024 election - it hit 46 million views and moved 5–7% of young, undecided men.
The fourth vector – often whispered rather than openly stated – is the cultural backlash. Pew 2025 surveys reveal 45% globally (70% among conservatives) say society is changing “too quickly” on gender and identity. Norris & Inglehart’s updated Cultural Backlash work finds traditional views on gender now boost radical-right support odds by 15–25%, independent of economics - and this is critical. Economics is not the sole driver, and it is not being forward-looking - it is the pace of change. Carnegie documents a global “anti-gender” wave since 2015. When schools teach pronoun policies or governments prioritise overseas aid while local services crumble, millions of former centrists feel the left has sprinted past them. The political centre has lost 15–20% support across Europe and North America since 2015, and roughly a quarter of those defectors explicitly cite “cultural extremes”.
The key is to see the convergence of these four vectors - often with malevolent outcomes. Illegal low-skilled migration stories, conflated with migration as a whole, explode on podcasts, fomenting resentment with persistent youth unemployment or underemployment, which gets channelled into “protect our women” rhetoric, and every viral clip of a pronoun debate convinces another moderate that the left no longer speaks for them. The result? A perfect storm that explains 40–50% of the right-wing surge since 2015 – far more than any single factor.
What I find particularly challenging with this trajectory is that populist wins deter high-skill migrants, worsen economic precarity, push progressive activists to double down, and feed ever-angrier content farms. The centre keeps bleeding. None of this means the right-wing wave is morally correct or that progressive goals are wrong. It simply means ordinary people, when hit simultaneously by economic insecurity, cultural vertigo, and a firehose of fear, reach for the nearest political lifeboat – and right now, that lifeboat is flying nationalist colours.
We will need firm intervention by the society, government and commerce, If we want to arrest this trend- slower cultural pacing, serious labour-market buffers for automation’s losers, transparent and firmer migration management, as well as a media environment that introduces some level of fact checking and transparency into the funding sources. If not, I am afraid the pendulum may swing too far – and the next stop may be further right than any of us imagined.
More in this area
New Zealand Needs a Government That Can Decide
The current election results have brought back all the reasons I have never been comfortable with MMP as the platform for New Zealand’s democracy. I think it brings back the arguments for a different architecture, not a minor…
Creating fiscal headspace by delivering outcomes and not just bills to taxpayers
I am watching the Conservative conference in Birmingham with some anticipation. The party chairman has promised more announcements about scrapping taxes before the week is out. Last week I wrote about Andy Burnham's first…
Youth, Tariffs, and India’s Strategic Autonomy Story
Two recent issues – the youth movement, new tariffs imposed ondemanded and Russian oil purchases and future tariffs of 100% on generics – made me reflect over the foreign policy posture of India. I have never been comfortable…