The Great Appropriation: Why Gold Just Overtook the Euro
I was struck by two news articles today: the EU appropriating Russian sovereign assets for Ukraine's rebuilding and defence, and the UK government issuing a license to compel Abramovich to contribute the proceeds of the Chelsea sale to Ukraine.
Whilst I wholeheartedly support the Ukrainian cause, I am deeply concerned about the precedent these twin initiatives will set for the future. We are witnessing a quiet dismantling of the financial order we grew up with.
Even after the collapse of Bretton-Woods, at least the rules of the "Bretton Woods II" game were clear: reserves were sacrosanct. Even in war, the path to reparations was diplomatic and treaty-based. The Treaty of Versailles, the Potsdam Agreement, and the UN Compensation Commission, which compelled Iraq to pay 3-5% of its oil revenues to Kuwait—these were negotiated settlements or international mandates recognized by legal consensus.
What is happening now in Brussels and London is fundamentally different. The EU's move to not just freeze (immobilize) but also appropriate (seize and spend) Russian sovereign assets is a unilateral crossing of the Rubicon.
This isn’t about defending Russia; it’s about analyzing risk. When you combine this geopolitical weaponization with the West’s deteriorating balance sheet, the "risk-free" status of Western debt is effectively dead.
Confidence in the USD-centric system rests on two pillars: Fiscal discipline and Property rights. These moves erode both.
I looked at data from the Federal Reserve (FRED) and the World Bank for the "rampant printing" narrative. It is starker than most realize:
Money Supply (M2): In 1995, the US M2 was approximately $3.6 trillion. As we close out 2025, that figure sits above $21 trillion. We have effectively printed our way through every crisis for three decades.
National Debt: In 1995, the US total public debt was roughly $4.9 trillion. Today, we are staring at over $36 trillion—and climbing.
The most important takeaway, for me, is that when you dilute the currency by 6x and leverage the sovereign balance sheet to insurmountable levels, Treasury bonds stop being a "store of value" and become "conditional promises." The market has already noticed. While headlines focus on the USD, the real casualty has been the Euro. In 2023-2024, the market value of global official gold holdings overtook the allocated value of Euro reserves. Gold is now the second-largest reserve asset on the planet, displacing the euro. Mainly because central banks—buying at a record clip of 1,000+ tonnes per year since 2022—are voting with their balance sheets. They are moving collateral out of the Western financial system and into physical vaults. If Treasuries and Bunds can be revoked by political decree, gold is the only remaining neutral asset. It has no counterparty risk. It cannot be frozen if you hold it domestically.
Additionally, the Abramovich Precedent moves this from Sovereign to Private. The British government’s pressure to compel Roman Abramovich to "contribute" the £2.5bn proceeds from the Chelsea sale to Ukraine is a terrifying signal for global capital. This is not freezing assets until a conflict ends. This is the mobilization of private property against the owner’s will, without a criminal conviction.
For Family Offices and Sovereign Wealth Funds, there is a stark message on the wall: Western custody is no longer a vault; it is a political jurisdiction. If you fall out of favor, your assets are not just frozen—they are funding your adversary. The weaponization of Western custody infrastructure acts as an accelerant for the decline of the USD and EUR. Our economic rivals are taking note of this.
There is no doubt in my mind that the USD will remain the dominant transactional currency for trade (network effects are sticky), but its role as the exclusive store of value is over. The plateauing of foreign Treasury holdings and the stalling of the USD share in the COFER data confirm this.
The consequences for us will be structural and expensive:
Sanctions Risk Priced In: Custody risk is now a line item. The IMF has explicitly noted that sanctions drive portfolios toward gold. This isn't theory; it's allocation.
Higher Funding Costs: As official sectors diversify away from USD/EUR, the structural demand for Western sovereign debt weakens. We will have to pay higher rates to attract capital that used to arrive automatically.
Bifurcation: We are moving toward a dual-layered system. A "Transactional Tier" where USD/EUR are used for payments, sitting on top of a thickened "Solvency Tier" where Gold acts as the final, un-seizable collateral.
The precedent set today by appropriating reserves will haunt Western funding markets for a generation. We are trading long-term credibility for short-term liquidity. It is a bad trade.
USD Nominal used, 1995-2025 data range where possible, Allocated COFER used along with annual average for gold, rather than year-end values.
https://data.imf.org/en/datasets/IMF.STA:COFER, https://data.imf.org/en/news/october%201%202025%20cofer, https://www.gold.org/goldhub/research/central-banks, https://www.imf.org/en/blogs/articles/2024/06/11/dollar-dominance-in-the-international-reserve-system-an-update, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/econographics/going-for-gold-does-the-dollars-declining-share-in-global-reserves-matter/
More in this area
Midterms and AI expenditure
A few people have asked me whether the midterms put the brakes on the AI buildout. I went back through the data, and my view is that 'Bluenami' :-) will change the pace and the cost of the AI buildout. They will not change its…
Debt, Inflation, and the Narrowing Room for Policy—The Rising Cost of Running the State
I listened to Andy Burnham’s first Labour conference speech as Prime Minister, as he set out a larger role for the British state: a national care service, more council housing, changes to pensions and greater public involvement…
When the Money Goes Nowhere — and Everywhere at Once
Today, I heard the phrase used by Sunaina Sinha , who described the current state of IPOs and the flood of capital into equity markets as the "Party of Capital". This resonated deeply with me. I may sound like a broken record to…