Munich’s Real Question: Does Europe Still Need a Cold War NATO?
I always find the Munich Security Conference more insightful than Davos. People here are more pragmatic, priorities more real, and the discussions impactful. This year, European leaders are meeting to discuss common defense, but the issue is not Russia or China—it's the United States.
Marco Rubio put it plainly: "The old world is gone. We live in a new era in geopolitics, and it's going to require all of us to re-examine what that looks like and what our role is going to be." The most honest framing Washington has offered Europe in years. The question is whether Europe, as one, can hear it and act on it.
The US spent $935 billion on defense in 2024 — 64% of total NATO spending. Germany, the UK, and France spent $93.7bn, $84.2bn, and $65bn, respectively. Combined: $243 billion. This cost represents less than 26% of America's total contribution. We cannot remediate or negotiate the funding issue; it is a long-term reality.
We need to address broader issues with capacity and capabilities, not just funding. Germany's Bundeswehr stands at 184,194 soldiers as of December 2025. The 2018 target of 203,000 was never met—21,826 short. NATO's long-term requirement stands at 260,000, while Germany's own army commander asserts a need for 460,000 soldiers. Meanwhile, 20% of non-enlisted and 28% of enlisted positions sit vacant. Over a quarter of new recruits leave after six months. And as Merz said, Germany is Europe's largest economy; it now needs to match its military to the might of its economy.
Europe needs to consider a more significant issue: what exactly is it preparing for? NATO was built to counter the Soviet Union—54,400 tanks, 50,000+ armored vehicles, 3 million troops, a nuclear arsenal peaking at 70,300 warheads, and a sprawling Warsaw Pact backed by an entire planned economy. That threat justified a transatlantic mega-alliance.
Today's Russia is not that. The number of casualties in Ukraine exceeds 1.2 million. An estimated 243,000–352,000 fatalities. Losses exceeding recruitment by 9,000 per month. Deploying T-62 tanks from the 1960s. As Rutte himself put it, the Russian advance moves at the "stilted speed of a garden snail." Russia's $147 billion defense budget, up 300% since 2021, is showing signs of plateauing. Combined with crippling economic sanctions, this is a country bleeding itself dry in a war it cannot decisively win.
China is a different mismatch. The PLA hasn't fought since 1979. RAND documents systemic issues: promotions based on loyalty over merit, centralized command that cripples adaptability, no combat-experienced NCO corps; and insufficient airlift for sustained overseas operations. Recent purges by President Xi left theater commands under inexperienced leadership. Impressive experimental hardware—but an untested military led by politically appointed officers is not the existential threat justifying a $1.6 trillion alliance.
Yet NATO's structure behaves as though the USSR still looms. Europe operates 20 fighter aircraft types versus America's four. Seventeen main battle tank models versus one. The European Commission estimates that lack of cooperation costs €25–100 billion annually — up to 36% of European military spending, wasted. Investment per soldier in the EU runs at one quarter of the US level. This is not a defence architecture — it's a bureaucracy with uniforms. As one of the generals said to me NATO stands for "Not Allowed To Operate".
Rutte insists Europe cannot go it alone: "If EU lawmakers think they can do without the US, keep on dreaming". Perhaps. But Rubio is telling them to decide: are you on this journey, and will you carry your weight? If not, where do you want to go — and do you have the political cohesion to get there?
I think the honest answer is a third path. Europe doesn't need to match America's trillion-dollar apparatus. It needs a NATO fit for purpose against actual threats: a depleted Russia and an untested China. Scale back the duplication, pool procurement, consolidate 20 fighter variants into four, bring the cost down to something fungible. Stop designing for the USSR. Start designing for the world we live in.
Rubio is right: this is an inflection point. The question is whether Europe treats it as a crisis or as permission to finally build something rational.
More in this area
The Donroe Doctrine’s bill has come due
Two regions just watched the same lesson arrive from opposite directions. On September 16th, the US House voted 262 to 159 to authorise tariffs of up to 100% on the world’s largest buyers of Russian oil. India sits second on that…
Underwriting the Chinese Economic Model
32 days in China, 15 cities and a very long, fascinating road trip - numerous first-hand experiences and so many conversations with entrepreneurs, factories, academics and new friends, leading to some reflections. I have talked…
Learning from China
China's transformation isn't a single story of speed—it's the coexistence of two vastly contrasting paces, aspirations, and pursuits running in parallel. A Huaqiangbei stall can prototype an AI device in three weeks; a Dafen…